1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:04,162
WWW.MY-SUBS.COM
1
00:00:17,695 --> 00:00:20,213
Previously on Proven Innocent...
2
00:00:20,438 --> 00:00:22,020
What's Sparrow Ridge, Heather?
3
00:00:24,478 --> 00:00:25,885
Do you think that any
of those other girls
4
00:00:25,922 --> 00:00:27,215
could have killed Rosemary?
5
00:00:27,345 --> 00:00:28,518
It's not impossible.
6
00:00:28,555 --> 00:00:30,890
NIKKI: Bodie... meet Nathan.
7
00:00:31,008 --> 00:00:32,648
It's why I've been afraid
to give this a real shot.
8
00:00:32,684 --> 00:00:34,043
You still want to do this?
9
00:00:34,085 --> 00:00:35,359
BELLOWS: Without the murder weapon,
10
00:00:35,396 --> 00:00:38,047
any new case against
Madeline Scott is a nonstarter.
11
00:00:38,338 --> 00:00:40,549
I've considered dredging Quarry Lake.
12
00:00:40,728 --> 00:00:42,573
LODGE: If you don't find anything,
13
00:00:42,610 --> 00:00:43,777
you'll be crucified.
14
00:00:43,814 --> 00:00:45,663
You can forget about becoming A.G.
15
00:00:46,471 --> 00:00:47,794
Dredge the lake.
16
00:00:52,836 --> 00:00:56,467
[METALLIC CREAKING]
17
00:00:59,387 --> 00:01:01,387
[MACHINERY WHIRRING]
18
00:01:06,635 --> 00:01:09,260
The drones have covered 76%
of the floor of the cove.
19
00:01:09,353 --> 00:01:11,270
We've discovered 11 potential
murder weapons.
20
00:01:11,307 --> 00:01:12,393
Make that 12.
21
00:01:12,430 --> 00:01:13,869
GRETA: Men and their toys.
22
00:01:13,938 --> 00:01:15,784
Is all this really necessary?
23
00:01:15,821 --> 00:01:17,687
Drones are more discreet than divers.
24
00:01:17,724 --> 00:01:19,789
And ten times more expensive.
25
00:01:20,924 --> 00:01:22,307
Isabel, would you mind?
26
00:01:22,368 --> 00:01:23,939
Of course.
27
00:01:25,619 --> 00:01:27,521
I would appreciate it
if you would not discuss
28
00:01:27,627 --> 00:01:29,269
the finances for this expedition
29
00:01:29,306 --> 00:01:30,595
in front of any of the employees.
30
00:01:30,674 --> 00:01:31,885
Don't worry, Gore.
31
00:01:31,992 --> 00:01:33,512
They already know you're violating
32
00:01:33,549 --> 00:01:35,769
a dozen campaign laws to pay for this.
33
00:01:35,806 --> 00:01:36,863
I have to keep it off the books
34
00:01:36,925 --> 00:01:38,580
so I can keep it out of the press.
35
00:01:38,652 --> 00:01:40,041
I'm gonna find the murder weapon.
36
00:01:40,119 --> 00:01:41,697
I'm gonna make an arrest.
37
00:01:41,830 --> 00:01:43,762
And not a single person
on the entire planet
38
00:01:43,799 --> 00:01:45,135
will care where the money came from.
39
00:01:45,189 --> 00:01:46,847
But if you don't find
the murder weapon,
40
00:01:46,884 --> 00:01:48,580
and the disclosures are made public,
41
00:01:48,631 --> 00:01:49,855
you're in a lot of trouble.
42
00:01:49,892 --> 00:01:51,340
Madeline Scott is guilty.
43
00:01:51,377 --> 00:01:53,438
I will go to my grave proving it.
44
00:01:53,525 --> 00:01:56,656
And your grave might
just be a prison cell.
45
00:01:59,712 --> 00:02:02,385
[DOORBELL BUZZING]
46
00:02:04,556 --> 00:02:06,038
[WHIMPERS]
47
00:02:06,209 --> 00:02:08,296
Oh, God, you're my hero.
48
00:02:09,197 --> 00:02:11,410
"Good morning, brother.
Thanks for waking up so early
49
00:02:11,447 --> 00:02:13,207
- and bringing me my coffee."
- Are these my muffins?
50
00:02:13,243 --> 00:02:15,241
"And muffins". Yeah.
51
00:02:15,486 --> 00:02:18,066
So I matched the initials
to a bunch of girls
52
00:02:18,103 --> 00:02:19,363
who went to our high school.
53
00:02:19,400 --> 00:02:21,425
All of them seem like the type
that would be involved
54
00:02:21,462 --> 00:02:22,827
in something strange like this,
55
00:02:22,864 --> 00:02:24,351
but there's a few I couldn't match.
56
00:02:24,455 --> 00:02:27,845
Okay, "JS", that's gonna be,
uh, Julie Selewicz,
57
00:02:27,947 --> 00:02:30,480
um, which would make that
Elaine Sweeney,
58
00:02:30,517 --> 00:02:33,330
Lisa Guzman and Lisa Harrington.
59
00:02:34,080 --> 00:02:35,198
How do you know all that?
60
00:02:35,235 --> 00:02:36,515
'Cause they were part of the cool crowd
61
00:02:36,551 --> 00:02:37,641
at Sacred Heart, and I had a thing
62
00:02:37,680 --> 00:02:38,932
for Catholic girls back in the day.
63
00:02:38,969 --> 00:02:40,296
Don't tell me you hooked up
64
00:02:40,338 --> 00:02:41,498
with all the girls at Sacred Heart.
65
00:02:41,534 --> 00:02:44,939
No, no, not all of them,
just... most of them.
66
00:02:45,034 --> 00:02:46,378
Mm-mmm.
67
00:02:50,649 --> 00:02:52,198
- I'm serious, get going.
- I'm going.
68
00:02:52,235 --> 00:02:53,500
I got it.
69
00:02:54,444 --> 00:02:55,923
You're getting really good at this.
70
00:02:56,018 --> 00:02:57,697
Oh, uh, feed Atticus.
71
00:02:58,101 --> 00:02:59,428
Gotcha.
72
00:03:00,814 --> 00:03:02,322
SNYDER: I was the leading expert
73
00:03:02,359 --> 00:03:04,564
on shaken baby syndrome in Cook County.
74
00:03:04,666 --> 00:03:07,111
I testified in hundreds of cases.
75
00:03:07,148 --> 00:03:09,347
[OVER TV]: We believed
a triad of symptoms,
76
00:03:09,400 --> 00:03:11,580
when manifested in isolation,
77
00:03:11,830 --> 00:03:13,811
could only be caused by a caretaker
78
00:03:14,051 --> 00:03:15,479
shaking a baby to death.
79
00:03:15,598 --> 00:03:16,908
But now we know that the triad
80
00:03:16,945 --> 00:03:19,441
can be caused by undiagnosed illnesses,
81
00:03:19,478 --> 00:03:22,227
head trauma or a combination.
82
00:03:22,374 --> 00:03:26,017
There are a lot of people in
prison who shouldn't be there.
83
00:03:26,826 --> 00:03:28,734
That's a lot of wrongful convictions.
84
00:03:28,771 --> 00:03:29,901
It's our worst nightmare.
85
00:03:29,938 --> 00:03:32,676
It's a nightmare my sister's
been living for ten years.
86
00:03:32,713 --> 00:03:34,885
She was convicted of shaking
her baby to death.
87
00:03:34,922 --> 00:03:37,213
EASY: Amelia Vandenhey. Six months old.
88
00:03:37,250 --> 00:03:38,816
Her mother, Gabrielle,
was alone with her
89
00:03:38,853 --> 00:03:41,605
the same day the medical
examiner said she was injured.
90
00:03:42,916 --> 00:03:44,244
Gabrielle was also diagnosed
91
00:03:44,281 --> 00:03:45,558
with severe postpartum depression.
92
00:03:45,595 --> 00:03:47,586
Which the prosecution twisted
to make her look
93
00:03:47,623 --> 00:03:49,007
like a homicidal maniac.
94
00:03:49,088 --> 00:03:50,396
Gabrielle knew she was depressed.
95
00:03:50,442 --> 00:03:52,459
It made her the most careful mother.
96
00:03:52,496 --> 00:03:54,494
She loved Amelia. She just...
97
00:03:54,531 --> 00:03:55,879
h-had a hard time showing it.
98
00:03:55,916 --> 00:03:58,556
Shaken baby cases have some
of the highest conviction rates.
99
00:03:58,616 --> 00:04:01,133
You convince a jury that
a defendant is a bad mother,
100
00:04:01,291 --> 00:04:03,508
most of the time, the
prosecution can just paper over
101
00:04:03,545 --> 00:04:04,698
any lack of physical evidence.
102
00:04:04,758 --> 00:04:05,949
But what really convicted her
103
00:04:05,986 --> 00:04:07,698
was the medical examiner's testimony.
104
00:04:07,858 --> 00:04:10,879
He said the only possible
cause of death was shaking.
105
00:04:10,916 --> 00:04:12,299
Who was the M.E.?
106
00:04:12,397 --> 00:04:13,855
He was.
107
00:04:16,856 --> 00:04:18,799
GABRIELLE:
Amelia hadn't cried for hours.
108
00:04:18,916 --> 00:04:20,158
I thought it was the first time
109
00:04:20,195 --> 00:04:22,269
that she had slept through the night.
110
00:04:24,056 --> 00:04:25,612
[CLEARS THROAT]
But when I checked on her,
111
00:04:25,649 --> 00:04:27,329
she wasn't moving.
112
00:04:28,170 --> 00:04:30,252
And her skin was ice-cold.
113
00:04:31,358 --> 00:04:33,432
It was the worst moment of my life.
114
00:04:33,799 --> 00:04:35,490
And then they said that I did it.
115
00:04:35,538 --> 00:04:37,096
And everyone turned on me,
116
00:04:37,133 --> 00:04:38,549
including my own husband.
117
00:04:38,619 --> 00:04:42,382
And I never even got a chance
to say goodbye to her.
118
00:04:42,838 --> 00:04:44,460
I'm so sorry, Gabrielle.
119
00:04:45,150 --> 00:04:47,646
I'm sorry that you went
through this, too.
120
00:04:48,322 --> 00:04:49,648
Thanks.
121
00:04:49,981 --> 00:04:51,676
EASY: The most damning
moment of your trial
122
00:04:51,713 --> 00:04:53,885
was when your mother-in-law
testified that you said
123
00:04:53,922 --> 00:04:56,148
you fantasized about
getting rid of your child.
124
00:04:56,447 --> 00:04:57,854
You know who she is, right?
125
00:04:57,899 --> 00:05:00,876
Deborah Vandenhey,
of the Chicago Vandenheys.
126
00:05:00,955 --> 00:05:02,127
Owners of one of the largest
127
00:05:02,164 --> 00:05:03,433
privately-owned banks in the U.S.
128
00:05:03,470 --> 00:05:04,564
So you didn't say that?
129
00:05:04,601 --> 00:05:06,127
No, I did say it.
130
00:05:07,969 --> 00:05:09,602
And it's horrible.
131
00:05:11,923 --> 00:05:14,407
All I wanted...
I wanted to be a good mom.
132
00:05:16,017 --> 00:05:17,588
But Amelia, uh...
133
00:05:18,135 --> 00:05:19,883
her crying...
134
00:05:21,230 --> 00:05:23,277
Her crying was like nails
on a chalkboard,
135
00:05:23,314 --> 00:05:24,925
and breastfeeding hurt.
136
00:05:25,064 --> 00:05:26,669
I didn't want to be around her.
137
00:05:26,752 --> 00:05:28,946
KIRSTEN: You didn't hurt her.
138
00:05:29,001 --> 00:05:31,478
I was afraid that I might.
139
00:05:32,653 --> 00:05:34,689
But I never did.
140
00:05:34,954 --> 00:05:36,287
I made sure of it.
141
00:05:36,324 --> 00:05:37,732
I took my meds.
142
00:05:38,049 --> 00:05:39,807
I saw my doctor.
143
00:05:41,455 --> 00:05:43,368
MADELINE: Tell us about
the day before Amelia died.
144
00:05:43,463 --> 00:05:44,830
Nothing...
145
00:05:45,752 --> 00:05:47,614
nothing happened.
146
00:05:47,963 --> 00:05:49,708
Literally, nothing.
147
00:05:50,174 --> 00:05:53,378
She slept, and I watched...
148
00:05:53,989 --> 00:05:55,631
and I watched her.
149
00:05:56,939 --> 00:05:59,783
I may not have known
how to connect to her,
150
00:05:59,820 --> 00:06:01,336
but I loved her.
151
00:06:01,464 --> 00:06:03,275
I didn't kill her.
152
00:06:04,525 --> 00:06:07,623
♪ ♪
153
00:06:21,325 --> 00:06:23,790
Imagine: you're a new mother
154
00:06:23,827 --> 00:06:26,114
struggling with postpartum depression,
155
00:06:26,215 --> 00:06:27,834
unable to bond with your baby
156
00:06:27,871 --> 00:06:30,007
- the way you're expected to.
- [BABY CRYING]
157
00:06:30,427 --> 00:06:32,059
Do you hide this feeling,
158
00:06:32,096 --> 00:06:34,850
and risk harming
yourself and your baby?
159
00:06:34,887 --> 00:06:38,164
Or do you confide in someone
your dark secret
160
00:06:38,242 --> 00:06:39,645
and risk their scorn?
161
00:06:39,726 --> 00:06:41,592
[BABY WAILING]
162
00:06:42,012 --> 00:06:45,022
If you're brave, you do the right thing
163
00:06:45,221 --> 00:06:47,105
and open up about your struggles.
164
00:06:47,142 --> 00:06:48,267
You make sure
165
00:06:48,304 --> 00:06:50,758
your baby is safe.
166
00:06:52,346 --> 00:06:55,676
But what happens if the baby
mysteriously dies,
167
00:06:55,818 --> 00:06:57,309
an overzealous prosecutor
168
00:06:57,346 --> 00:06:59,207
uses your honesty against you,
169
00:06:59,294 --> 00:07:01,371
a doctor you don't even know
170
00:07:01,465 --> 00:07:03,410
testifies that science,
171
00:07:03,447 --> 00:07:07,920
says that you shook...
your baby... to death?
172
00:07:09,449 --> 00:07:11,031
How do you go on?
173
00:07:11,879 --> 00:07:13,262
How do you keep from thinking,
174
00:07:13,299 --> 00:07:15,236
that you should have hidden your truth,
175
00:07:15,313 --> 00:07:18,005
pocketed it away and just...
176
00:07:18,268 --> 00:07:20,060
endured the pain?
177
00:07:21,118 --> 00:07:24,082
On this week's episode
of Until Proven Innocent,
178
00:07:24,119 --> 00:07:26,840
we'll discuss the case
of Gabrielle Parcell,
179
00:07:26,925 --> 00:07:28,768
a woman who told her truth,
180
00:07:28,821 --> 00:07:30,830
and she paid for her honesty.
181
00:07:31,543 --> 00:07:33,129
But now...
182
00:07:33,166 --> 00:07:35,381
she has the opportunity to fight back.
183
00:07:35,476 --> 00:07:37,966
SNYDER: Illnesses
like meningitis, hemophilia,
184
00:07:37,994 --> 00:07:41,160
even vitamin deficiencies,
mimic the signs of SBS.
185
00:07:41,247 --> 00:07:44,480
Common household accidents like
falling from a seated position
186
00:07:44,636 --> 00:07:47,248
can cause the type of head
trauma I observed in this case.
187
00:07:47,285 --> 00:07:48,725
MADELINE: In light of
recent advancements
188
00:07:48,761 --> 00:07:49,988
in medical science,
189
00:07:50,072 --> 00:07:51,668
in your expert opinion,
190
00:07:51,768 --> 00:07:54,105
what was the cause of death
of Amelia Vandenhey?
191
00:07:54,277 --> 00:07:56,340
Head trauma.
But it's impossible to know
192
00:07:56,377 --> 00:07:58,099
the cause of that
without further testing.
193
00:07:58,155 --> 00:07:59,538
Thank you.
194
00:08:01,785 --> 00:08:05,287
Shaken baby syndrome is still
a legitimate diagnosis, correct?
195
00:08:05,324 --> 00:08:06,465
Objection.
196
00:08:06,527 --> 00:08:08,918
Shaken baby syndrome is an
accusation, not a diagnosis.
197
00:08:08,996 --> 00:08:11,254
- Sustained.
- I'll rephrase.
198
00:08:11,379 --> 00:08:14,637
In your expert opinion, is it possible,
199
00:08:14,674 --> 00:08:16,067
to shake a baby to death?
200
00:08:16,104 --> 00:08:17,474
It is. But I would only
201
00:08:17,511 --> 00:08:19,097
determine that to be the cause of death
202
00:08:19,134 --> 00:08:20,804
if I had excluded everything else.
203
00:08:20,886 --> 00:08:22,918
And when Amelia's tiny,
204
00:08:22,955 --> 00:08:24,356
cold corpse was on your examination...
205
00:08:24,393 --> 00:08:25,963
EASY: Objection! Inflammatory.
206
00:08:26,000 --> 00:08:28,785
Sustained. Ms. Moriarty,
I'm loath to agree
207
00:08:28,822 --> 00:08:30,613
with Ms. Scott and Mr. Boudreau,
208
00:08:30,650 --> 00:08:31,724
but what are we doing here?
209
00:08:31,761 --> 00:08:33,762
There's no jury present.
Spare the theatrics.
210
00:08:33,799 --> 00:08:36,287
Theatrics are what these cases
are all about, Your Honor.
211
00:08:36,324 --> 00:08:38,618
That was not an invitation to
the peanut gallery, Ms. Scott.
212
00:08:38,638 --> 00:08:39,743
Zip it.
213
00:08:39,972 --> 00:08:41,523
There's a witness. Use him.
214
00:08:41,699 --> 00:08:44,443
MORIARTY: Dr. Snyder,
you testified at trial
215
00:08:44,480 --> 00:08:46,943
that the only day
Amelia could have been injured
216
00:08:46,980 --> 00:08:48,887
was the day before she died,
didn't you?
217
00:08:48,964 --> 00:08:51,631
I did. But my expert opinion
has changed.
218
00:08:51,651 --> 00:08:53,062
Will it change again tomorrow?
219
00:08:53,099 --> 00:08:55,191
- BOTH: Objection!
- I get the gist, Ms. Moriarty.
220
00:08:55,277 --> 00:08:57,443
But, counselors,
without a specific reason
221
00:08:57,480 --> 00:09:00,215
to believe there may have been
another cause of death,
222
00:09:00,298 --> 00:09:02,787
I'm not inclined to vacate
a murder conviction.
223
00:09:02,824 --> 00:09:04,520
But, Judge, we're merely seeking access
224
00:09:04,557 --> 00:09:06,817
to the autopsy slides
and tissue samples
225
00:09:06,854 --> 00:09:09,045
so we can determine if something
else caused Amelia's death.
226
00:09:09,082 --> 00:09:10,742
Y-Your Honor, i-if I may.
227
00:09:10,861 --> 00:09:13,061
I just want to make sure
I didn't get it wrong.
228
00:09:13,800 --> 00:09:14,850
Fine.
229
00:09:14,922 --> 00:09:17,831
Motion to inspect
the scientific evidence granted.
230
00:09:18,268 --> 00:09:19,496
Court adjourned.
231
00:09:19,651 --> 00:09:21,418
[ELEVATOR BELL DINGS]
232
00:09:23,254 --> 00:09:25,201
You should be ashamed of yourself.
233
00:09:25,293 --> 00:09:27,387
Hiring a couple of shyster lawyers,
234
00:09:27,424 --> 00:09:29,004
to dredge up these horrid memories
235
00:09:29,041 --> 00:09:30,754
- of my poor granddaughter.
- Please, Deborah,
236
00:09:30,791 --> 00:09:32,271
you don't care about Amelia.
237
00:09:32,347 --> 00:09:34,607
You don't care
about anyone but yourself.
238
00:09:34,644 --> 00:09:36,099
- Kirsten, that's not fair.
- Shut up, Clay.
239
00:09:36,136 --> 00:09:38,049
All right, let's all just stay calm.
240
00:09:38,152 --> 00:09:39,782
Hi. I'm Madeline Scott.
241
00:09:39,830 --> 00:09:41,574
Easy Boudreau, shyster-at-law.
242
00:09:41,611 --> 00:09:43,270
You people are profiting
243
00:09:43,307 --> 00:09:45,513
off a lunatic woman and her dead baby.
244
00:09:45,550 --> 00:09:47,391
- She killed my granddaughter.
- [ELEVATOR BELL DINGS]
245
00:09:47,428 --> 00:09:50,003
What my mother is trying to say is...
246
00:09:50,437 --> 00:09:52,543
Your family is trash.
247
00:09:57,729 --> 00:09:59,729
- Classy.
- EASY: Hmm.
248
00:10:01,095 --> 00:10:02,902
SNYDER: This is evidence
of a brain bleed.
249
00:10:03,019 --> 00:10:05,308
Ten years ago I saw one brain bleed
250
00:10:05,379 --> 00:10:07,847
which started within 24 hours
before death.
251
00:10:07,884 --> 00:10:09,992
But with new medical advances,
252
00:10:10,029 --> 00:10:12,521
I can slice the tissue samples thinner
253
00:10:12,558 --> 00:10:13,707
and see blood leveling,
254
00:10:13,744 --> 00:10:15,512
which shows this brain
bleed started earlier.
255
00:10:15,549 --> 00:10:16,844
So, the prosecution's theory
256
00:10:16,902 --> 00:10:18,543
that Amelia was injured on Tuesday...
257
00:10:18,580 --> 00:10:19,582
Was wrong.
258
00:10:19,619 --> 00:10:22,166
Amelia could have been injured
up to five days earlier.
259
00:10:22,327 --> 00:10:23,746
When someone else was with her.
260
00:10:23,824 --> 00:10:25,354
Do you know what could have
caused the injury?
261
00:10:25,453 --> 00:10:27,923
I've ruled out most illnesses,
except one.
262
00:10:28,281 --> 00:10:31,207
If she had something called
factor XIII clotting disorder,
263
00:10:31,244 --> 00:10:33,597
much less force... like something
264
00:10:33,634 --> 00:10:35,709
as simple as a fall on the floor...
265
00:10:35,752 --> 00:10:36,910
could have been fatal.
266
00:10:36,947 --> 00:10:38,328
Why didn't you bring this up at trial?
267
00:10:38,365 --> 00:10:40,207
I saw the triad, did a basic check
268
00:10:40,244 --> 00:10:41,309
for other medical problems...
269
00:10:41,346 --> 00:10:43,272
I assumed it was shaken baby.
270
00:10:43,487 --> 00:10:45,271
And when the prosecutor
told me the mother
271
00:10:45,308 --> 00:10:49,157
had postpartum depression,
I got confirmation bias.
272
00:10:49,194 --> 00:10:51,621
[SIGHS] Medical tunnel vision.
273
00:10:51,768 --> 00:10:53,767
Right. So, what now?
274
00:10:53,836 --> 00:10:55,606
I can run a blood coagulation panel
275
00:10:55,643 --> 00:10:56,980
to determine if she had the disorder,
276
00:10:57,018 --> 00:10:58,834
but... I need blood samples
277
00:10:58,902 --> 00:11:00,238
- from both parents.
- EASY: Hmm.
278
00:11:00,285 --> 00:11:02,066
Well, mom's not gonna
be a problem, but...
279
00:11:02,183 --> 00:11:04,208
But the dad? Mama's boy?
280
00:11:04,761 --> 00:11:06,472
He just might be.
281
00:11:06,800 --> 00:11:09,435
So, if Amelia could die
from a random accident,
282
00:11:09,472 --> 00:11:11,604
there could be hundreds
of women in prison for shaking
283
00:11:11,665 --> 00:11:13,145
their babies, when really,
it was something
284
00:11:13,181 --> 00:11:15,144
as simple as a fall on the floor.
285
00:11:15,260 --> 00:11:18,016
Sadly... yes.
286
00:11:19,550 --> 00:11:21,006
Oh, my God.
287
00:11:26,222 --> 00:11:29,136
♪ ♪
288
00:11:32,683 --> 00:11:33,880
CLAY: If it was a disease,
289
00:11:33,917 --> 00:11:35,467
wouldn't they have
already discovered it?
290
00:11:35,504 --> 00:11:37,722
Once "SBS" was written
in Amelia's file,
291
00:11:37,759 --> 00:11:39,672
investigators stopped looking
for a disease
292
00:11:39,709 --> 00:11:41,074
and started looking for a murderer.
293
00:11:41,183 --> 00:11:42,744
MADELINE: There's a
chance your daughter died
294
00:11:42,781 --> 00:11:44,048
of a congenital blood disorder.
295
00:11:44,085 --> 00:11:44,903
To know for sure,
296
00:11:44,940 --> 00:11:46,378
we're gonna need a
blood sample from you.
297
00:11:46,415 --> 00:11:48,519
You didn't see
how Gabrielle was acting.
298
00:11:48,980 --> 00:11:51,004
She wouldn't even go near Amelia.
299
00:11:51,426 --> 00:11:52,603
Broke my heart.
300
00:11:52,640 --> 00:11:54,316
That was postpartum depression.
301
00:11:54,526 --> 00:11:56,687
It doesn't mean she killed Amelia.
302
00:11:57,002 --> 00:11:58,453
[EASY SIGHS]
303
00:12:00,972 --> 00:12:02,207
You know, we just learned
304
00:12:02,244 --> 00:12:04,173
prosecution got the timeline wrong.
305
00:12:05,029 --> 00:12:07,185
They could have got
a lot of things wrong.
306
00:12:08,568 --> 00:12:11,920
If it were my kid, I'd want to
know what really happened.
307
00:12:15,847 --> 00:12:17,324
Okay.
308
00:12:17,903 --> 00:12:19,644
Okay, I'll do the blood test.
309
00:12:19,681 --> 00:12:21,050
But for Amelia.
310
00:12:21,174 --> 00:12:22,867
Not for Gabrielle.
311
00:12:24,708 --> 00:12:26,605
The whole Nathan thing just kind of...
312
00:12:26,728 --> 00:12:28,957
- well, it surprised me.
- Yeah.
313
00:12:29,482 --> 00:12:30,802
You should have told me
about it earlier
314
00:12:30,839 --> 00:12:32,355
so I didn't make a fool of myself.
315
00:12:32,392 --> 00:12:34,059
[CHUCKLES]
316
00:12:34,193 --> 00:12:37,606
Well, I'm sorry.
But I'm new at this, too.
317
00:12:37,824 --> 00:12:39,895
But you told me you wanted
to get real, you know,
318
00:12:39,932 --> 00:12:41,449
Nathan's a big part of my life,
319
00:12:41,486 --> 00:12:42,506
and you want to be in my life,
320
00:12:42,543 --> 00:12:43,903
- you got to know about Nathan.
- I do. I...
321
00:12:43,939 --> 00:12:46,338
I do. I'm crazy about you.
322
00:12:46,951 --> 00:12:48,175
But...?
323
00:12:48,457 --> 00:12:50,246
But-but nothing.
324
00:12:50,353 --> 00:12:52,131
I'm just processing this.
325
00:12:54,133 --> 00:12:55,815
Oh, all right, okay.
326
00:12:55,852 --> 00:12:58,475
Well, uh, you keep processing.
327
00:12:59,006 --> 00:13:00,663
I'm gonna take care of Nathan.
328
00:13:00,700 --> 00:13:02,033
What, you're leaving?
329
00:13:02,070 --> 00:13:04,332
Yeah. I got to pick up the kid.
330
00:13:04,963 --> 00:13:07,467
- Okay.
- Look, um...
331
00:13:07,888 --> 00:13:10,423
no hard feelings
if this is too much reality.
332
00:13:10,460 --> 00:13:12,021
We started off just having fun.
333
00:13:12,058 --> 00:13:15,256
So I get it if this is too deep.
334
00:13:15,898 --> 00:13:17,300
Thanks.
335
00:13:17,538 --> 00:13:19,961
That's actually really cool of you.
336
00:13:20,121 --> 00:13:21,539
[LAUGHING]: Yeah, well...
337
00:13:21,614 --> 00:13:23,706
uh, you're basically
a man-child anyway,
338
00:13:23,743 --> 00:13:25,609
so it's probably a really bad idea.
339
00:13:25,854 --> 00:13:27,562
Take care, Bodie.
340
00:13:30,345 --> 00:13:31,843
- [DOOR CLOSES]
- [CHUCKLES]
341
00:13:31,880 --> 00:13:33,754
A man-child?
342
00:13:37,156 --> 00:13:38,483
EASY: All right, bad news.
343
00:13:38,580 --> 00:13:40,469
Clay tested negative
for the blood disorder,
344
00:13:40,506 --> 00:13:42,239
which means Amelia didn't die
of an illness.
345
00:13:42,326 --> 00:13:43,694
So something else happened.
346
00:13:43,731 --> 00:13:44,804
We just need to figure out what.
347
00:13:44,841 --> 00:13:46,296
I don't want to rain on everyone's...
348
00:13:46,333 --> 00:13:47,444
innocence parade here,
349
00:13:47,481 --> 00:13:48,939
but it's not looking good
for our client.
350
00:13:48,976 --> 00:13:51,034
We don't know if there was
abuse, Bodie.
351
00:13:51,259 --> 00:13:53,808
All we know is that Amelia was injured
352
00:13:53,845 --> 00:13:55,398
- the week before she died.
- Right.
353
00:13:55,435 --> 00:13:57,248
And it could have been
Gabrielle who did it.
354
00:13:57,285 --> 00:13:58,686
She said she wanted
to get rid of the baby.
355
00:13:58,723 --> 00:14:00,628
Look at the M.E.'s report
a little bit closer.
356
00:14:00,693 --> 00:14:02,831
You'll see that there's a bruise
across Amelia's chest.
357
00:14:02,895 --> 00:14:04,262
It looks like a belt mark.
358
00:14:04,323 --> 00:14:05,882
That's evidence of abuse.
359
00:14:05,919 --> 00:14:07,543
Or it's evidence of an accident.
360
00:14:07,628 --> 00:14:09,721
Maybe an accident caused
both the chest bruise
361
00:14:09,758 --> 00:14:10,933
and the head trauma.
362
00:14:10,970 --> 00:14:12,650
A fall from as little as one foot high
363
00:14:12,687 --> 00:14:14,036
can generate twice the force
364
00:14:14,073 --> 00:14:15,689
an adult can generate
shaking an infant.
365
00:14:15,726 --> 00:14:18,230
Yeah, but that leaves us
with an almost impossible task.
366
00:14:18,307 --> 00:14:20,141
How do we find out if an infant fell
367
00:14:20,178 --> 00:14:21,319
ten years after the fact?
368
00:14:21,356 --> 00:14:23,719
We investigate. We keep searching,
369
00:14:23,756 --> 00:14:25,390
but we don't give up.
370
00:14:45,838 --> 00:14:47,821
♪ ♪
371
00:15:06,576 --> 00:15:09,005
[GRUNTING]
372
00:15:27,104 --> 00:15:29,071
♪ ♪
373
00:15:52,699 --> 00:15:55,289
GABRIELLE: If this was an
accident, then this is my fault.
374
00:15:55,326 --> 00:15:57,152
- You can't think that way, Gabby.
- No...
375
00:15:57,189 --> 00:15:58,846
I was her mother.
376
00:15:59,274 --> 00:16:01,474
I was supposed to-to protect her.
377
00:16:01,511 --> 00:16:04,167
Something happened to Amelia,
and I didn't know.
378
00:16:04,204 --> 00:16:05,539
MADELINE: I know this is difficult,
379
00:16:05,576 --> 00:16:06,949
but we need your help
if we're going to get
380
00:16:06,986 --> 00:16:09,155
to the bottom of this
and get you out of here.
381
00:16:09,871 --> 00:16:12,168
The medical examiner
from your first trial
382
00:16:12,205 --> 00:16:14,082
now thinks that the
injury could have happened
383
00:16:14,119 --> 00:16:17,495
as many as five days
before Amelia's death.
384
00:16:18,251 --> 00:16:20,126
Do you remember any accidents?
385
00:16:20,463 --> 00:16:22,387
I was hazy on antidepressants,
386
00:16:22,424 --> 00:16:24,360
so I stayed in my room a lot.
387
00:16:24,865 --> 00:16:26,832
The mother-in-law, Deborah,
388
00:16:27,091 --> 00:16:29,793
was taking care of her quite a bit.
389
00:16:30,927 --> 00:16:32,427
Wait.
390
00:16:33,581 --> 00:16:34,950
What?
391
00:16:35,664 --> 00:16:37,154
There was a car accident.
392
00:16:37,272 --> 00:16:39,093
- Are you serious?
- Yeah. It was, uh,
393
00:16:39,130 --> 00:16:40,847
four days before Amelia died.
394
00:16:40,884 --> 00:16:41,991
Clay was driving her
395
00:16:42,028 --> 00:16:43,585
to a doctor's appointment with Deborah.
396
00:16:43,622 --> 00:16:44,704
How bad was the accident?
397
00:16:44,741 --> 00:16:46,272
Clay said it wasn't bad at all, but I
398
00:16:46,309 --> 00:16:48,830
I remember that his car
needed some body work.
399
00:16:49,220 --> 00:16:51,444
My attorney at trial told me,
400
00:16:51,481 --> 00:16:52,638
that that was irrelevant,
401
00:16:52,675 --> 00:16:55,747
'cause he said that the injuries
definitely happened on Tuesday.
402
00:16:57,944 --> 00:17:00,084
- Is it possible?
- Yes.
403
00:17:00,506 --> 00:17:02,086
It's very possible.
404
00:17:02,892 --> 00:17:04,325
It's a big lead.
405
00:17:12,670 --> 00:17:13,967
VIOLET: I seriously doubt.
406
00:17:14,004 --> 00:17:16,578
Deborah Vandenhey is gonna talk to us.
407
00:17:17,373 --> 00:17:18,573
Sure she will.
408
00:17:18,610 --> 00:17:20,701
Rich ladies understand
the power of a subpoena.
409
00:17:20,738 --> 00:17:22,855
[LAUGHS]
Believe me, she'd rather answer
410
00:17:22,892 --> 00:17:24,534
our questions here than in court.
411
00:17:24,749 --> 00:17:26,483
VIOLET [CHUCKLES]: Wow.
412
00:17:26,828 --> 00:17:28,328
DEBORAH: Nothing stands out
413
00:17:28,365 --> 00:17:30,523
about the week before Amelia died.
414
00:17:30,872 --> 00:17:33,268
My son and I were taking care of her.
415
00:17:33,341 --> 00:17:36,006
Unfortunately, her mother
was no help whatsoever.
416
00:17:36,043 --> 00:17:38,110
Well, we understand
that you and your son
417
00:17:38,147 --> 00:17:39,803
got into a car accident with her.
418
00:17:39,873 --> 00:17:41,534
The fender bender?
419
00:17:41,595 --> 00:17:45,280
Amelia was strapped into
her rear-facing car seat.
420
00:17:45,388 --> 00:17:46,807
Nothing happened to her.
421
00:17:46,875 --> 00:17:48,592
She slept through the whole thing.
422
00:17:48,629 --> 00:17:50,162
And you never took her to the doctor?
423
00:17:50,238 --> 00:17:52,092
As a matter of fact, we did.
424
00:17:52,241 --> 00:17:54,303
We were on our way to see him anyway.
425
00:17:54,373 --> 00:17:56,089
He checked Amelia thoroughly.
426
00:17:56,126 --> 00:17:57,588
She didn't even have a bruise.
427
00:17:57,794 --> 00:18:00,128
Did anyone other than you and Clay
428
00:18:00,170 --> 00:18:02,353
help to look after the baby,
like, um...
429
00:18:02,390 --> 00:18:04,382
- like a nanny?
- Maybe Charles here.
430
00:18:04,419 --> 00:18:06,911
DEBORAH: I don't believe
in outsourcing childcare.
431
00:18:06,950 --> 00:18:10,441
Charles cares for the house,
not for the people in it.
432
00:18:10,565 --> 00:18:11,880
Thank you, Charles.
433
00:18:11,988 --> 00:18:15,530
Do you remember Amelia
having a fall of any kind?
434
00:18:15,567 --> 00:18:17,114
Off a bed or a couch?
435
00:18:17,151 --> 00:18:18,809
No, I don't.
436
00:18:18,927 --> 00:18:20,863
Amelia didn't fall.
437
00:18:21,134 --> 00:18:24,069
And as I understand it,
the timeline may have shifted,
438
00:18:24,106 --> 00:18:26,429
but that doesn't mean
Gabrielle didn't shake her.
439
00:18:26,619 --> 00:18:29,354
But there were other people
alone with Amelia.
440
00:18:29,583 --> 00:18:31,403
For example, her father, Clay.
441
00:18:31,440 --> 00:18:33,770
And Clay had a son
from his first marriage.
442
00:18:33,856 --> 00:18:36,216
Uh, Declan.
He was ten at the time, right?
443
00:18:36,309 --> 00:18:38,441
Declan was away at boarding school.
444
00:18:38,601 --> 00:18:41,231
He only had the pleasure
of meeting Amelia once,
445
00:18:41,268 --> 00:18:42,469
when she was born.
446
00:18:42,545 --> 00:18:44,711
And Clay was wonderful with Amelia.
447
00:18:44,942 --> 00:18:46,608
You seem very convinced.
448
00:18:46,645 --> 00:18:50,345
This is a strong, loving
and tight-knit family.
449
00:18:50,489 --> 00:18:54,427
We take care of our children.
We love our children.
450
00:18:54,524 --> 00:18:56,749
We protect our children.
451
00:18:56,853 --> 00:18:59,194
The only harm that came to Amelia
452
00:18:59,231 --> 00:19:01,631
was at the hands of a woman
I deeply regret
453
00:19:01,668 --> 00:19:03,442
ever married my son.
454
00:19:03,570 --> 00:19:07,047
I told Clay she wasn't
good enough for our family,
455
00:19:07,364 --> 00:19:10,223
and I was tragically right.
456
00:19:11,388 --> 00:19:12,793
Charles?
457
00:19:13,520 --> 00:19:14,911
Now, if that's all,
458
00:19:14,985 --> 00:19:17,361
Charles will see you out.
459
00:19:20,608 --> 00:19:22,075
Hi, Charles.
460
00:19:24,663 --> 00:19:26,597
[INDISTINCT CHATTER]
461
00:19:27,350 --> 00:19:29,989
♪ ♪
462
00:19:43,221 --> 00:19:44,846
Declan Vandenhey?
463
00:19:45,524 --> 00:19:47,191
- Yeah.
- I'm Bodie Quick.
464
00:19:47,228 --> 00:19:48,503
Ezekiel Boudreau.
465
00:19:48,540 --> 00:19:51,249
We represent your stepmom,
Gabrielle Parcell.
466
00:19:51,841 --> 00:19:53,091
Gabrielle's in prison.
467
00:19:53,167 --> 00:19:54,851
We work on wrongful conviction cases.
468
00:19:55,778 --> 00:19:56,932
You think she didn't do it?
469
00:19:56,969 --> 00:19:59,005
There's new science that shows
she probably didn't.
470
00:19:59,210 --> 00:20:00,831
We'd like to ask you
a few questions about
471
00:20:00,868 --> 00:20:01,885
who was taking care of Amelia.
472
00:20:01,922 --> 00:20:03,588
I can't talk right now. I'm at work.
473
00:20:03,801 --> 00:20:05,409
Work study?
474
00:20:05,552 --> 00:20:07,719
What is this, an exercise
in character building?
475
00:20:08,143 --> 00:20:09,671
What do you mean?
476
00:20:09,768 --> 00:20:11,517
I mean, there are buildings
on this campus
477
00:20:11,536 --> 00:20:12,807
named after your family.
478
00:20:12,909 --> 00:20:14,870
You don't exactly need help
with tuition.
479
00:20:14,948 --> 00:20:18,252
I'm not close to my grandmother.
I don't want her money.
480
00:20:18,434 --> 00:20:20,559
And I can't help you.
I barely knew Amelia.
481
00:20:20,712 --> 00:20:22,632
Why aren't you close to your
grandmother? What happened?
482
00:20:22,675 --> 00:20:24,866
Look, I don't want to have
anything to do with that family.
483
00:20:25,065 --> 00:20:27,082
Truly terrible people.
484
00:20:27,469 --> 00:20:28,916
BODIE: How about your dad?
485
00:20:29,087 --> 00:20:30,980
How did he behave
after Amelia was born?
486
00:20:31,017 --> 00:20:32,087
[SIGHS]
487
00:20:32,124 --> 00:20:33,996
I don't want anything to
do with my dad, either.
488
00:20:34,643 --> 00:20:36,502
I don't even speak to him, okay?
489
00:20:37,104 --> 00:20:40,446
And like I said,
I have to get back to work.
490
00:20:43,735 --> 00:20:46,069
[INDISTINCT CHATTER]
491
00:20:46,251 --> 00:20:47,869
There's nothing more touching
492
00:20:47,906 --> 00:20:49,454
than a loving and devoted son.
493
00:20:49,491 --> 00:20:50,572
Why do you think Declan has a
494
00:20:50,609 --> 00:20:52,631
terrible relationship with his dad?
495
00:20:52,689 --> 00:20:53,870
I don't know.
496
00:20:53,907 --> 00:20:55,462
Infidelity to his mother.
497
00:20:55,554 --> 00:20:57,062
Emotionally unavailable.
498
00:20:57,205 --> 00:20:59,087
- A thousand ways to screw up a kid.
- [EASY LAUGHS]
499
00:20:59,124 --> 00:21:00,470
Parenthood is a minefield.
500
00:21:00,592 --> 00:21:01,866
Like you would know.
501
00:21:02,228 --> 00:21:03,818
Look, here's the thing.
502
00:21:05,094 --> 00:21:06,757
So, Nikki's got a kid.
503
00:21:07,339 --> 00:21:09,486
She... Her sister has a kid.
504
00:21:09,523 --> 00:21:10,696
Had-had a kid.
505
00:21:10,820 --> 00:21:13,087
Nikki's... Nikki's raising
a kid. That's the deal.
506
00:21:13,157 --> 00:21:14,785
Damn. Scaring you off?
507
00:21:14,946 --> 00:21:16,744
No. I thought about it a lot.
508
00:21:16,781 --> 00:21:18,306
- I'm not scared.
- No.
509
00:21:18,343 --> 00:21:20,017
- I'm terrified.
- Oh...
510
00:21:20,054 --> 00:21:22,087
She called me a man-child,
and she's right.
511
00:21:22,124 --> 00:21:23,360
I dress up like a ninja.
512
00:21:23,428 --> 00:21:24,768
What makes one a man-child
513
00:21:24,805 --> 00:21:26,581
can also make them a terrific father.
514
00:21:26,618 --> 00:21:27,728
- Yeah?
- You might have
515
00:21:27,765 --> 00:21:29,405
a great relationship with the kid.
516
00:21:30,135 --> 00:21:31,439
Yeah.
517
00:21:32,220 --> 00:21:34,027
Or I'll stab him
with a sword by accident,
518
00:21:34,064 --> 00:21:35,769
and then you and Madeline
will have to exonerate me
519
00:21:35,806 --> 00:21:37,087
for ninja baby syndrome.
520
00:21:37,124 --> 00:21:38,932
All right, listen, here's the thing.
521
00:21:39,227 --> 00:21:41,004
You're never ready to have a kid.
522
00:21:41,314 --> 00:21:43,400
Irene and I did everything
according to plan,
523
00:21:43,437 --> 00:21:45,475
and I live in a hotel now.
524
00:21:46,565 --> 00:21:48,220
We got separated.
525
00:21:48,525 --> 00:21:50,115
Dude. You all right?
526
00:21:50,173 --> 00:21:52,284
Hey, listen.
I love everything about my kids.
527
00:21:52,362 --> 00:21:53,953
I wouldn't undo anything in my life.
528
00:21:54,018 --> 00:21:55,351
So you're saying I should do this.
529
00:21:55,388 --> 00:21:57,788
Uh, I can't make that decision for you.
530
00:21:57,985 --> 00:21:59,704
Come on, Easy, please. Please.
531
00:21:59,741 --> 00:22:01,657
Please make this decision for me, man.
532
00:22:01,717 --> 00:22:04,618
Yeah, you got to decide
for yourself, brother.
533
00:22:09,211 --> 00:22:11,026
EASY: He truly hates his father.
534
00:22:11,198 --> 00:22:12,572
Is it possible Clay was abusive
535
00:22:12,609 --> 00:22:13,962
and the mother didn't see it?
536
00:22:14,032 --> 00:22:15,964
- Or didn't want to?
- It's possible,
537
00:22:16,001 --> 00:22:18,069
but Clay seemed genuinely hopeful about
538
00:22:18,106 --> 00:22:20,106
finding out what happened to Amelia.
539
00:22:20,540 --> 00:22:21,831
Can I help you?
540
00:22:21,895 --> 00:22:24,605
I'm Frances Bonnett,
Clay Vandenhey's ex-wife.
541
00:22:24,642 --> 00:22:26,946
I got a phone call
from Ezekiel Boudreau.
542
00:22:26,983 --> 00:22:28,298
Just call me Easy.
543
00:22:28,335 --> 00:22:29,501
Come on in.
544
00:22:29,538 --> 00:22:31,422
FRANCES: I felt sorry for Gabrielle.
545
00:22:31,999 --> 00:22:34,569
I wanted to warn her
about the Vandenheys.
546
00:22:35,110 --> 00:22:36,868
But when Clay and I divorced,
547
00:22:36,905 --> 00:22:39,188
I received a substantial settlement.
548
00:22:39,931 --> 00:22:41,004
That came with strings.
549
00:22:41,077 --> 00:22:43,144
- You signed an NDA.
- If I talk to you
550
00:22:43,181 --> 00:22:44,670
about anything, an army of lawyers
551
00:22:44,707 --> 00:22:46,626
will come and take
everything that I have.
552
00:22:46,831 --> 00:22:48,713
And you have something to say.
553
00:22:49,388 --> 00:22:51,923
You could have told us
about the NDA over the phone.
554
00:22:52,906 --> 00:22:54,798
MADELINE: Just point us
in the right direction.
555
00:22:54,970 --> 00:22:57,251
I promise we won't
bring you into it at all.
556
00:23:03,600 --> 00:23:05,783
There was abuse in that family.
557
00:23:06,181 --> 00:23:07,992
- MADELINE: Clay?
- No.
558
00:23:08,767 --> 00:23:10,362
He was the one being abused...
559
00:23:10,790 --> 00:23:12,549
by Deborah.
560
00:23:12,709 --> 00:23:14,366
She beat him as a kid.
561
00:23:16,103 --> 00:23:18,634
And I can't prove it, but
I think she hurt Declan, too.
562
00:23:18,678 --> 00:23:20,367
MADELINE: What makes you say that?
563
00:23:21,676 --> 00:23:23,189
When Declan was eight,
564
00:23:23,306 --> 00:23:25,469
he came home from a weekend
at Grandma's lake house
565
00:23:25,506 --> 00:23:26,796
with a broken arm.
566
00:23:27,449 --> 00:23:29,583
She told me he fell off a horse.
567
00:23:31,461 --> 00:23:33,610
But by the way he was acting...
568
00:23:34,298 --> 00:23:36,153
I know when my son's lying to me.
569
00:23:36,767 --> 00:23:38,329
I tried to tell Clay.
570
00:23:38,431 --> 00:23:40,726
But Deborah has a weird hold on him.
571
00:23:41,142 --> 00:23:43,868
So then I sent Declan
to boarding school, and...
572
00:23:43,956 --> 00:23:45,237
[CLEARS THROAT] ...Clay and I broke up
573
00:23:45,273 --> 00:23:46,444
a few months later.
574
00:23:46,613 --> 00:23:49,072
Do you think Deborah hurt Amelia?
575
00:23:50,659 --> 00:23:52,610
It wouldn't surprise me.
576
00:23:53,187 --> 00:23:54,683
At all.
577
00:23:59,665 --> 00:24:01,894
You don't find what you want,
so you just start
578
00:24:01,931 --> 00:24:03,507
accusing other members
of my family, huh?
579
00:24:03,602 --> 00:24:05,222
We understand your anger, Clay,
580
00:24:05,259 --> 00:24:06,774
but we know your mother abused you.
581
00:24:06,811 --> 00:24:08,610
- You don't know anything!
- EASY: We do.
582
00:24:08,673 --> 00:24:10,095
We know you're a grown man who needs
583
00:24:10,132 --> 00:24:11,590
to stop covering for his mother.
584
00:24:11,946 --> 00:24:14,470
We know that your mother abused
you and your son Declan.
585
00:24:14,507 --> 00:24:16,431
My mother never laid a hand on Declan.
586
00:24:17,185 --> 00:24:18,517
[SIGHS]
587
00:24:21,056 --> 00:24:22,993
Remember Declan's
horseback riding accident
588
00:24:23,030 --> 00:24:24,805
when he was eight years old?
589
00:24:28,904 --> 00:24:30,758
Been talking to my ex-wife.
590
00:24:31,884 --> 00:24:33,386
Your ex-wife signed an NDA.
591
00:24:33,423 --> 00:24:35,631
We've been talking to a lot of people.
592
00:24:36,918 --> 00:24:38,376
[SIGHS]
593
00:24:38,524 --> 00:24:41,733
You knew Declan didn't fall
off that horse, didn't you?
594
00:24:49,329 --> 00:24:52,206
Declan told us
he doesn't speak to you anymore.
595
00:24:52,427 --> 00:24:54,803
That he doesn't want
anything to do with you.
596
00:25:01,076 --> 00:25:02,808
Isn't reconciling with your son
597
00:25:02,845 --> 00:25:05,611
more important than protecting
your abusive mother?
598
00:25:09,019 --> 00:25:11,135
She can't hurt you anymore.
599
00:25:14,525 --> 00:25:16,118
Declan was...
600
00:25:16,234 --> 00:25:18,301
an exceptional rider.
601
00:25:20,165 --> 00:25:21,790
I didn't want to believe
that she was doing to him
602
00:25:21,827 --> 00:25:23,660
the same thing that she had done to me.
603
00:25:23,887 --> 00:25:25,419
MADELINE: She hurt him.
604
00:25:25,517 --> 00:25:26,817
And you.
605
00:25:28,244 --> 00:25:31,003
Don't you think it's possible
she also hurt Amelia?
606
00:25:31,243 --> 00:25:33,352
No. No.
607
00:25:33,519 --> 00:25:35,228
No, she loved Amelia.
608
00:25:35,290 --> 00:25:37,676
I'm sure she loved you and Declan, too.
609
00:25:38,018 --> 00:25:40,477
But this has got to stop now.
610
00:25:46,314 --> 00:25:47,686
If she did something to hurt Amelia,
611
00:25:47,706 --> 00:25:50,039
I know who would have
helped her cover it up.
612
00:25:51,939 --> 00:25:53,626
Does your mother know you're here?
613
00:25:53,692 --> 00:25:55,618
I don't need
her permission for anything.
614
00:25:55,738 --> 00:25:57,485
Especially if it concerns
my own children.
615
00:25:57,556 --> 00:25:59,531
Declan is now over 18.
616
00:25:59,595 --> 00:26:01,959
So the law says I can
only share his records with him.
617
00:26:02,006 --> 00:26:04,775
As for Amelia,
we closed her file years ago.
618
00:26:04,911 --> 00:26:06,294
Uh, I'll have to search for it.
619
00:26:06,349 --> 00:26:08,534
- I'll get it back to you.
- That sounds like a runaround.
620
00:26:11,751 --> 00:26:13,275
Every time my mother hurt me,
621
00:26:13,312 --> 00:26:15,368
I got to come see Dr. O'Barr.
622
00:26:15,642 --> 00:26:17,717
You gave me candy,
you spoke to me kindly,
623
00:26:17,754 --> 00:26:20,208
but you never reported it
to the police, did you?
624
00:26:20,245 --> 00:26:23,320
I don't know what
you're talking about, Clay.
625
00:26:24,946 --> 00:26:26,107
Sure you do.
626
00:26:26,282 --> 00:26:27,726
I spent ten years in prison
627
00:26:27,746 --> 00:26:30,340
and the next seven
practicing criminal law.
628
00:26:31,001 --> 00:26:32,681
I've seen all kinds of evil.
629
00:26:33,020 --> 00:26:34,642
But a pediatrician who profits from
630
00:26:34,679 --> 00:26:36,291
covering up child abuse...
631
00:26:36,372 --> 00:26:37,772
MADELINE: Got to be
the worst kind of evil.
632
00:26:37,809 --> 00:26:39,250
VIOLET: Special place in Hell
type of evil.
633
00:26:39,286 --> 00:26:40,336
Careful.
634
00:26:40,376 --> 00:26:43,167
Spurious allegations
are called defamation.
635
00:26:43,204 --> 00:26:45,367
Actually, it's only defamation
if it isn't true.
636
00:26:45,446 --> 00:26:47,189
I think you people need to leave.
637
00:26:48,657 --> 00:26:49,901
We're leaving.
638
00:26:49,993 --> 00:26:51,392
But we're not going away.
639
00:26:51,445 --> 00:26:52,712
We'll be back with a subpoena.
640
00:26:52,771 --> 00:26:55,067
And after we find what we need
in those records...
641
00:26:55,104 --> 00:26:57,337
We're gonna make it all public.
642
00:26:58,145 --> 00:26:59,870
I'm sure someone else will be back
643
00:26:59,907 --> 00:27:01,641
for your medical license.
644
00:27:07,631 --> 00:27:09,178
Yeah, it's Jeffrey.
645
00:27:12,438 --> 00:27:14,061
Oh, my goodness, Mrs. Vandenhey,
646
00:27:14,098 --> 00:27:16,219
you can't just barge in here,
without an appointment.
647
00:27:16,256 --> 00:27:17,617
- This is highly inappropriate.
- I don't need an appointment.
648
00:27:17,653 --> 00:27:19,100
- You realize...
- Who the Hell
649
00:27:19,137 --> 00:27:20,486
do you people think you are?
650
00:27:20,523 --> 00:27:22,298
- Hello, Mrs. Vandenhey.
- Jeffrey called me
651
00:27:22,335 --> 00:27:24,110
the minute you left his office.
652
00:27:24,193 --> 00:27:25,718
You can't go around harassing
653
00:27:25,755 --> 00:27:27,080
the people who work for me.
654
00:27:27,121 --> 00:27:28,849
We can if they're protecting
child abusers.
655
00:27:28,886 --> 00:27:31,616
Isn't that precisely
what you people are doing?
656
00:27:31,653 --> 00:27:33,108
You're protecting the abuser
657
00:27:33,145 --> 00:27:34,241
who was convicted,
658
00:27:34,278 --> 00:27:35,748
of murdering my granddaughter.
659
00:27:35,785 --> 00:27:37,295
That's not what it looks like to us.
660
00:27:37,332 --> 00:27:38,437
We spoke to your son.
661
00:27:38,474 --> 00:27:40,107
You manipulated him.
662
00:27:40,280 --> 00:27:43,077
My lawyers are drafting
a cease and desist order.
663
00:27:43,114 --> 00:27:44,633
Then a lawsuit.
664
00:27:44,670 --> 00:27:47,498
We'll destroy you
with legal fees alone.
665
00:27:47,567 --> 00:27:49,864
- You scared, Easy?
- Petrified.
666
00:27:50,879 --> 00:27:52,846
What are you afraid we'll find?
667
00:27:53,341 --> 00:27:55,675
You may have bullied my son, Ms. Scott,
668
00:27:55,950 --> 00:27:57,834
but you won't bully me.
669
00:27:58,303 --> 00:27:59,728
Kate.
670
00:27:59,796 --> 00:28:01,346
[VIOLET GRUNTS]
671
00:28:08,045 --> 00:28:09,848
LEVI: Okay, so I think I figured out,
672
00:28:09,885 --> 00:28:11,053
who all the girls are.
673
00:28:11,670 --> 00:28:14,091
Get this. All these girls...
674
00:28:14,240 --> 00:28:15,397
they were there that night.
675
00:28:15,697 --> 00:28:17,423
[INDISTINCT CHATTER]
676
00:28:27,118 --> 00:28:29,243
I also pulled the deed
from that creepy house.
677
00:28:29,280 --> 00:28:31,389
It turns out it was owned
by some company called
678
00:28:31,426 --> 00:28:34,122
Karna-Surya-Kunti, Inc.
679
00:28:34,500 --> 00:28:36,670
"Surya" means sun in Sanskrit.
680
00:28:37,092 --> 00:28:39,410
Right, right, you just
happen to know that?
681
00:28:39,592 --> 00:28:41,522
I did a lot of reading
in the prison library.
682
00:28:41,671 --> 00:28:43,264
Eastern religions was a fave.
683
00:28:43,387 --> 00:28:44,522
Okay.
684
00:28:44,611 --> 00:28:46,586
Hey, by the way, check this out.
685
00:28:46,666 --> 00:28:49,146
This is a painting from
another room in the house.
686
00:28:49,183 --> 00:28:52,224
They made it into some sort of
spiritual room or something.
687
00:28:52,261 --> 00:28:53,988
What's this "R" about?
688
00:28:54,141 --> 00:28:56,050
It's got to be a name, right?
689
00:28:56,389 --> 00:28:57,748
All right, if we stay in Eastern names,
690
00:28:57,785 --> 00:29:01,022
there's Raj, uh, Rishni, Rashneesh.
691
00:29:01,059 --> 00:29:03,322
Ravi is the Hindu God of the sun.
692
00:29:05,880 --> 00:29:08,380
Wow. Okay, this is getting
really weird.
693
00:29:08,465 --> 00:29:10,165
No. It actually makes perfect sense.
694
00:29:10,275 --> 00:29:11,861
Eastern religious symbolism,
695
00:29:11,898 --> 00:29:15,241
drugs, a secretive group
of young girls.
696
00:29:16,325 --> 00:29:17,998
- Levi, it was a cult.
- Oh, come on.
697
00:29:18,035 --> 00:29:20,753
You really believe that-that
Rosemary would join a cult?
698
00:29:20,834 --> 00:29:22,496
I think that, clearly,
we didn't know her
699
00:29:22,533 --> 00:29:24,232
as well as we thought we did.
700
00:29:24,462 --> 00:29:26,939
Okay, if "R" is a person's name,
701
00:29:27,127 --> 00:29:28,709
then that has to be the leader, right?
702
00:29:28,746 --> 00:29:30,856
- Right.
- Every cult has a guru.
703
00:29:31,954 --> 00:29:34,579
Keith Raniere,
Bhagwan Shree Rajneesh...
704
00:29:34,616 --> 00:29:37,754
- Charles Manson.
- All charismatic manipulators
705
00:29:37,855 --> 00:29:40,397
who promise enlightenment, and then...
706
00:29:40,575 --> 00:29:41,768
dupe their followers
707
00:29:41,813 --> 00:29:43,963
into doing whatever they want.
708
00:29:44,106 --> 00:29:46,248
Keith Raniere had all his girls
709
00:29:46,285 --> 00:29:48,470
on a crazy low-calorie diet.
710
00:29:48,963 --> 00:29:51,053
Kept them skinny and mentally unstable.
711
00:29:51,090 --> 00:29:52,762
Well, that would explain the Adderall.
712
00:29:52,799 --> 00:29:54,199
That's what I'm thinking.
713
00:29:54,615 --> 00:29:56,248
ROSEMARY: Do you want to
be a virgin in college?
714
00:29:56,285 --> 00:29:57,436
No. Do you?
715
00:29:57,473 --> 00:30:00,256
No. So let's get it over with.
716
00:30:02,662 --> 00:30:04,186
Right before she died,
717
00:30:04,223 --> 00:30:07,111
Rosemary was fixated on
us losing our virginity.
718
00:30:07,385 --> 00:30:10,194
I thought it was about the two
of us going off to college.
719
00:30:10,670 --> 00:30:12,310
It was probably this.
720
00:30:12,389 --> 00:30:13,796
You think she was recruiting you.
721
00:30:13,853 --> 00:30:15,787
All I know is that this cult
722
00:30:15,824 --> 00:30:17,248
is the key to what happened that night.
723
00:30:17,285 --> 00:30:18,655
We have to talk to Linda Barrett again.
724
00:30:18,692 --> 00:30:20,719
No, Heather Husband has
Linda Barrett shut down,
725
00:30:20,756 --> 00:30:22,186
she's scared to talk.
726
00:30:22,278 --> 00:30:23,856
Who else is there?
727
00:30:24,252 --> 00:30:26,502
Oh, let me see.
728
00:30:28,086 --> 00:30:29,561
Wait.
729
00:30:29,776 --> 00:30:31,174
Sarah Tawney.
730
00:30:31,252 --> 00:30:33,510
She sent me a Christmas card in prison.
731
00:30:33,678 --> 00:30:35,811
She said she believed we were innocent.
732
00:30:37,761 --> 00:30:40,270
Maybe that's because
she knows who's guilty.
733
00:30:41,092 --> 00:30:42,580
SARAH: I was under his spell.
734
00:30:42,648 --> 00:30:44,736
We all were. He was so handsome.
735
00:30:45,514 --> 00:30:47,597
Listen, did you, um...
736
00:30:48,795 --> 00:30:50,928
did you have sex with Ravi?
737
00:30:53,765 --> 00:30:55,098
What did Linda tell you?
738
00:30:55,586 --> 00:30:58,721
She said that...
you all had sex with him.
739
00:31:00,162 --> 00:31:03,389
He made us believe that sex was
the path to enlightenment.
740
00:31:03,655 --> 00:31:05,226
It was so screwed up.
741
00:31:05,344 --> 00:31:06,936
But at the time,
it felt like my salvation.
742
00:31:06,973 --> 00:31:08,147
High school was horrible for me.
743
00:31:08,184 --> 00:31:10,288
I was... insecure, fat.
744
00:31:10,325 --> 00:31:11,778
I didn't know where I belonged.
745
00:31:11,867 --> 00:31:13,086
I was...
746
00:31:14,015 --> 00:31:16,170
Maybe it's a teenage girl thing, but...
747
00:31:16,447 --> 00:31:17,803
I felt unworthy.
748
00:31:17,928 --> 00:31:19,410
Ravi changed all that.
749
00:31:19,476 --> 00:31:21,699
So, how long was Rosemary in the group?
750
00:31:22,055 --> 00:31:23,606
She was one of the first to join.
751
00:31:23,701 --> 00:31:26,111
She loved it. Rosemary had a wild side.
752
00:31:26,833 --> 00:31:29,139
She instantly became Ravi's favorite.
753
00:31:31,004 --> 00:31:33,671
That... piss the other girls off?
754
00:31:35,097 --> 00:31:37,189
It pissed off Heather Dupinski.
755
00:31:37,647 --> 00:31:40,225
She was the star
until Rosemary came along.
756
00:31:41,496 --> 00:31:43,366
Listen, um...
757
00:31:43,766 --> 00:31:45,397
do you think that-that...
758
00:31:45,577 --> 00:31:49,145
Heather... could have possibly
killed Rosemary over this?
759
00:31:49,863 --> 00:31:51,187
Look, I-I got to get back to work.
760
00:31:51,224 --> 00:31:52,864
I'd really appreciate
if you didn't tell anybody
761
00:31:52,900 --> 00:31:54,476
I was involved in all of this.
I just...
762
00:31:54,614 --> 00:31:56,579
Even though it happened
a long time ago,
763
00:31:56,616 --> 00:31:58,421
it really screwed my life up.
764
00:31:58,458 --> 00:31:59,765
- Please?
- I'll get going.
765
00:31:59,802 --> 00:32:01,218
Thank you for this information.
766
00:32:01,255 --> 00:32:02,814
Yeah.
767
00:32:08,967 --> 00:32:11,167
What are you doing with my money?
768
00:32:11,782 --> 00:32:13,815
- Hi, Rick.
- Hello, Gore.
769
00:32:13,905 --> 00:32:15,116
What do you mean, your money?
770
00:32:15,241 --> 00:32:16,335
I'm hearing whispers,
771
00:32:16,372 --> 00:32:17,765
about my funds being used
772
00:32:17,802 --> 00:32:20,587
for non-campaign activities.
773
00:32:20,928 --> 00:32:23,721
Come on, Gore,
I've got ears everywhere.
774
00:32:24,499 --> 00:32:26,198
Okay. I'll tell you.
775
00:32:26,328 --> 00:32:29,245
But I have to ask for your discretion.
776
00:32:30,596 --> 00:32:32,334
This is really big.
I don't want it to leak.
777
00:32:32,453 --> 00:32:35,563
Well, I'm nothing if not discreet.
778
00:32:37,083 --> 00:32:40,131
The money went to the campaign,
in a manner of speaking.
779
00:32:40,563 --> 00:32:44,006
I used it to search the lake
at Cathedral Cove.
780
00:32:46,261 --> 00:32:47,881
Why'd you do that?
781
00:32:47,980 --> 00:32:49,513
To finish what I started.
782
00:32:49,945 --> 00:32:52,564
And the campaign manager
you thrust on me told me
783
00:32:52,601 --> 00:32:54,053
if I found new evidence
784
00:32:54,184 --> 00:32:56,405
implicating Madeline Scott
in the Lynch murder,
785
00:32:56,453 --> 00:32:58,338
I would dominate every news cycle.
786
00:32:58,462 --> 00:32:59,999
Well, he's right.
787
00:33:00,067 --> 00:33:01,237
[CHUCKLES]
788
00:33:01,391 --> 00:33:03,716
So, did you?
789
00:33:06,723 --> 00:33:08,041
This old lantern
790
00:33:08,078 --> 00:33:10,580
matches the head wound
on Rosemary Lynch.
791
00:33:12,382 --> 00:33:15,096
I finally found the murder
weapon, after all these years.
792
00:33:15,133 --> 00:33:16,438
Let me see that.
793
00:33:20,361 --> 00:33:21,957
- You sure about that, huh?
- Yes.
794
00:33:21,994 --> 00:33:24,494
The M.E. confirmed it.
The contusion in her skull
795
00:33:24,531 --> 00:33:26,164
matches that lantern.
796
00:33:26,201 --> 00:33:29,386
The same metal fragments
were lodged in her brain.
797
00:33:29,623 --> 00:33:30,679
It's just a matter of time,
798
00:33:30,716 --> 00:33:32,522
before I connect it to Madeline Scott.
799
00:33:32,700 --> 00:33:35,568
This isn't a lark, Rick.
This is justice.
800
00:33:35,844 --> 00:33:38,511
I would sacrifice my entire
political career for it.
801
00:33:38,823 --> 00:33:42,475
Well, if you can connect
this lantern to Madeline Scott,
802
00:33:42,512 --> 00:33:44,745
you won't have to sacrifice anything.
803
00:33:45,520 --> 00:33:48,687
You arrest her
before the polls close...
804
00:33:49,447 --> 00:33:51,739
...you'll win by a landslide.
805
00:33:54,362 --> 00:33:56,748
It looks like they covered
their tracks pretty well.
806
00:33:56,858 --> 00:33:58,725
Yep. Nothing but general
wellness checkups
807
00:33:58,762 --> 00:33:59,967
and standard blood tests.
808
00:34:00,011 --> 00:34:02,558
O'Barr is their private
concierge doctor.
809
00:34:02,663 --> 00:34:03,718
If they had something to hide,
810
00:34:03,755 --> 00:34:05,471
he may not have kept a record of it.
811
00:34:06,387 --> 00:34:07,983
VIOLET: Wait a second.
812
00:34:08,986 --> 00:34:11,366
Didn't Deborah say that Declan
was at boarding school
813
00:34:11,403 --> 00:34:13,001
in the days before the baby's death?
814
00:34:13,038 --> 00:34:15,998
Yes, when she was bragging
about not outsourcing childcare.
815
00:34:16,035 --> 00:34:18,294
Well, it says here he got a flu shot
816
00:34:18,331 --> 00:34:20,228
on the Saturday before Amelia died.
817
00:34:20,661 --> 00:34:21,915
He was home?
818
00:34:22,008 --> 00:34:23,686
Why would Deborah lie about that?
819
00:34:25,319 --> 00:34:26,879
DECLAN: I already told
you, I have nothing more
820
00:34:26,915 --> 00:34:27,741
to say about my father.
821
00:34:27,778 --> 00:34:29,138
MADELINE: What about your grandmother?
822
00:34:29,174 --> 00:34:30,718
- What about her?
- She said you were at school
823
00:34:30,755 --> 00:34:31,995
the week your sister died,
824
00:34:32,032 --> 00:34:34,334
but Dr. O'Barr gave you
a flu shot on Saturday.
825
00:34:34,371 --> 00:34:35,462
You were home.
826
00:34:35,499 --> 00:34:37,093
Why would your grandmother
lie about that?
827
00:34:37,130 --> 00:34:38,512
You should ask her.
828
00:34:39,264 --> 00:34:41,428
Were you with Amelia
that weekend, Declan?
829
00:34:41,465 --> 00:34:43,516
- Did something happen?
- N-No.
830
00:34:43,623 --> 00:34:45,366
Doctor said Amelia got hurt on Tuesday.
831
00:34:45,403 --> 00:34:46,629
I was already back at school.
832
00:34:46,666 --> 00:34:48,368
The doctor's timeline was revised.
833
00:34:48,466 --> 00:34:49,694
It shows Amelia's injury
834
00:34:49,731 --> 00:34:51,772
probably happened over the weekend.
835
00:34:57,113 --> 00:34:58,506
The weekend?
836
00:34:59,264 --> 00:35:00,788
Yes.
837
00:35:03,762 --> 00:35:07,388
Declan, we know that
your grandmother hurt you
838
00:35:07,600 --> 00:35:10,179
and that she asked you
to keep quiet about everything.
839
00:35:10,881 --> 00:35:12,218
I... I can't.
840
00:35:12,255 --> 00:35:13,746
EASY: Hey, hey, Declan.
841
00:35:14,147 --> 00:35:15,980
Abuse is cyclical.
842
00:35:16,380 --> 00:35:18,522
Now, you were only doing
what you were taught.
843
00:35:21,074 --> 00:35:23,041
It's time to break the cycle.
844
00:35:26,536 --> 00:35:28,294
[CRYING]
845
00:35:30,026 --> 00:35:31,909
I think it was me.
846
00:35:32,059 --> 00:35:34,092
[SNIFFLES]
847
00:35:34,279 --> 00:35:36,326
I think I killed her.
848
00:35:39,046 --> 00:35:41,605
DECLAN: Gabrielle wouldn't
come out of her room.
849
00:35:41,771 --> 00:35:43,725
They said she was depressed.
850
00:35:44,197 --> 00:35:46,438
My dad was playing golf,
851
00:35:46,798 --> 00:35:50,350
so it was just my grandma and I
taking care of Amelia.
852
00:35:50,504 --> 00:35:53,149
She asked me to watch her
while she went to the bathroom.
853
00:35:55,635 --> 00:35:57,350
We were in the kitchen.
854
00:35:58,265 --> 00:35:59,611
I was...
855
00:35:59,899 --> 00:36:02,175
I was trying to watch a video.
856
00:36:03,912 --> 00:36:06,246
Amelia wouldn't stop crying.
857
00:36:07,786 --> 00:36:09,858
I got irritated.
858
00:36:11,011 --> 00:36:12,975
I kicked the high chair.
859
00:36:14,186 --> 00:36:16,098
It-it slid across the floor,
860
00:36:16,161 --> 00:36:18,328
and she slammed her head
against the wall.
861
00:36:20,213 --> 00:36:21,704
MADELINE: Your Honor,
862
00:36:22,044 --> 00:36:25,713
this is the make of high chair
that the family used.
863
00:36:29,241 --> 00:36:31,061
Note that the bruising on Amelia
864
00:36:31,098 --> 00:36:33,404
is consistent
with the high chair strap.
865
00:36:35,900 --> 00:36:38,881
Declan, what happened
after Amelia hit her head?
866
00:36:39,976 --> 00:36:41,698
I asked my grandmother
867
00:36:42,076 --> 00:36:43,609
if it was my fault.
868
00:36:44,108 --> 00:36:47,069
And she said no,
that it was Gabrielle's.
869
00:36:47,607 --> 00:36:49,607
That Gabrielle never wanted Amelia.
870
00:36:49,906 --> 00:36:53,782
She made me swear never to tell
anyone what happened.
871
00:36:55,357 --> 00:36:57,131
In my family...
872
00:36:57,280 --> 00:36:59,139
you learn to do as you're told
873
00:36:59,446 --> 00:37:01,413
or suffer the consequences.
874
00:37:02,191 --> 00:37:04,525
Declan, what are the consequences?
875
00:37:08,584 --> 00:37:11,229
When I was eight and talked back,
876
00:37:11,304 --> 00:37:14,022
Grandma twisted my arm so hard
she broke it.
877
00:37:16,118 --> 00:37:18,256
She told my mom I fell off a horse.
878
00:37:21,104 --> 00:37:24,622
My first memory... ever
879
00:37:24,811 --> 00:37:28,233
is of my grandma throwing
a marble chess piece at my head.
880
00:37:28,483 --> 00:37:30,093
My dad was clueless,
881
00:37:30,130 --> 00:37:32,607
but my mom f-figured out...
882
00:37:33,983 --> 00:37:37,034
I'm so sorry, Gabby. I-I didn't know.
883
00:37:39,618 --> 00:37:41,594
I didn't know.
884
00:37:42,306 --> 00:37:44,273
Thank you, Declan.
885
00:37:45,974 --> 00:37:47,941
Nothing further, Your Honor.
886
00:37:50,910 --> 00:37:52,507
No questions, Your Honor.
887
00:37:52,598 --> 00:37:53,648
MADELINE: Your Honor,
888
00:37:53,684 --> 00:37:54,702
the defense moves to vacate...
889
00:37:54,739 --> 00:37:56,360
JUDGE: I'll save you the
trouble, Ms. Scott.
890
00:37:56,467 --> 00:37:57,903
Ms. Parcell,
891
00:37:58,949 --> 00:38:00,885
I would like to personally apologize
892
00:38:00,922 --> 00:38:02,481
for everything you've been through
893
00:38:02,569 --> 00:38:05,695
and offer condolences
for the death of your child.
894
00:38:06,037 --> 00:38:07,489
You're free to go.
895
00:38:10,435 --> 00:38:11,735
[GAVEL BANGING]
896
00:38:11,849 --> 00:38:13,305
One moment, please.
897
00:38:13,513 --> 00:38:14,693
While it's not part
898
00:38:14,730 --> 00:38:16,750
of the current matter
before this court,
899
00:38:16,832 --> 00:38:18,982
I find it necessary to address
900
00:38:19,082 --> 00:38:21,958
Deborah Vandenhey directly.
901
00:38:23,613 --> 00:38:25,958
If not for the statute of limitations,
902
00:38:25,995 --> 00:38:30,088
I would issue a warrant for your
arrest on charges of perjury,
903
00:38:30,125 --> 00:38:32,948
obstruction of justice and child abuse.
904
00:38:32,985 --> 00:38:35,052
This court cannot punish you.
905
00:38:35,158 --> 00:38:37,170
But rest assured, madam,
906
00:38:37,253 --> 00:38:38,755
you will be judged harshly
907
00:38:38,792 --> 00:38:41,138
in the court of public opinion.
908
00:38:41,648 --> 00:38:43,708
- Court adjourned.
- [GAVEL BANGS]
909
00:38:44,126 --> 00:38:46,126
[GALLERY MURMURING QUIETLY]
910
00:38:51,477 --> 00:38:54,114
Thank you. Thank you.
911
00:38:54,408 --> 00:38:56,366
- You're welcome.
- [BOTH LAUGHING]
912
00:38:58,034 --> 00:38:59,521
I'm glad we finally got to the truth.
913
00:38:59,558 --> 00:39:01,535
- Clay, don't even start.
- No, no.
914
00:39:02,528 --> 00:39:06,063
I don't know what to say,
e-except I'm sorry.
915
00:39:06,563 --> 00:39:08,130
For everything.
916
00:39:08,508 --> 00:39:09,915
I appreciate that.
917
00:39:09,952 --> 00:39:12,527
- I'm so, so sorry, Gabrielle.
- Oh, no. No.
918
00:39:12,564 --> 00:39:14,129
It was an accident.
919
00:39:14,466 --> 00:39:18,013
You were just a child,
and I don't blame you at all.
920
00:39:18,373 --> 00:39:20,686
So please don't blame yourself.
921
00:39:21,711 --> 00:39:23,419
Mom.
922
00:39:25,134 --> 00:39:27,857
VIOLET: Criminal prosecutions
are about punishment,
923
00:39:27,894 --> 00:39:29,315
not healing.
924
00:39:29,671 --> 00:39:31,700
But when I look around,
I don't see a world
925
00:39:31,737 --> 00:39:34,513
that's lacking in retribution.
926
00:39:35,129 --> 00:39:37,458
- I see a world suffering.
- [REPORTERS CLAMORING]
927
00:39:37,707 --> 00:39:40,631
There is a deep, dark pain stirring
928
00:39:40,688 --> 00:39:42,170
in many of us.
929
00:39:42,331 --> 00:39:45,107
We're afraid to be shaken
out of that pain
930
00:39:45,144 --> 00:39:48,087
because it feels safe and familiar.
931
00:39:49,025 --> 00:39:51,509
Like we need it to survive.
932
00:39:52,614 --> 00:39:54,448
But the opposite is true.
933
00:39:54,535 --> 00:39:57,736
We need to shine a light
onto the darkness.
934
00:39:58,102 --> 00:40:00,376
We need to face that pain
935
00:40:00,703 --> 00:40:02,159
and see it,
936
00:40:02,935 --> 00:40:04,326
because that is the only way
937
00:40:04,363 --> 00:40:06,547
we will truly heal.
938
00:40:07,037 --> 00:40:08,147
BODIE: Hey, you made it!
939
00:40:08,184 --> 00:40:09,344
Come on in here. It's freezing out.
940
00:40:09,380 --> 00:40:10,860
How you doing, little man?
941
00:40:10,945 --> 00:40:12,850
What do you think?
Handshake? Fist bump?
942
00:40:12,949 --> 00:40:16,342
Slap me some skin like 1977. No...?
943
00:40:16,414 --> 00:40:17,881
- How about a hug?
- Yeah.
944
00:40:17,918 --> 00:40:19,381
- [CHUCKLES]
- Oh, what is that?
945
00:40:19,418 --> 00:40:20,811
Who brought the hot dogs
946
00:40:20,848 --> 00:40:23,081
and the chicken tenders
and the chips and the...
947
00:40:23,118 --> 00:40:24,175
Do you like that stuff?
948
00:40:24,212 --> 00:40:25,378
- Yes.
- Get it.
949
00:40:25,508 --> 00:40:27,576
BODIE: Like a Dobermann
in a meat factory.
950
00:40:27,613 --> 00:40:30,068
So, uh, hey, what are we doing here?
951
00:40:30,196 --> 00:40:32,869
- We're eating junk food.
- Yeah, I can see that.
952
00:40:34,672 --> 00:40:37,225
I've been working on this case, right?
953
00:40:37,475 --> 00:40:38,709
And it's made me realize that
954
00:40:38,746 --> 00:40:40,925
if kids don't have strong role models,
955
00:40:41,145 --> 00:40:42,881
they can get pretty screwed up.
956
00:40:44,256 --> 00:40:46,490
- So...?
- So...
957
00:40:47,559 --> 00:40:49,201
you make me a better person.
958
00:40:49,270 --> 00:40:52,062
And I think that
I might even be able to be
959
00:40:52,146 --> 00:40:54,499
a good example for Nathan.
960
00:40:54,733 --> 00:40:57,225
And I love you,
and I think that maybe together,
961
00:40:57,262 --> 00:40:59,262
you-you and me could ma...
962
00:41:02,194 --> 00:41:03,578
NATHAN: Gross.
963
00:41:03,615 --> 00:41:05,257
NIKKI: Hey, k-kissing's not gross.
964
00:41:05,294 --> 00:41:06,511
- Yeah, it is.
- [LAUGHTER]
965
00:41:06,604 --> 00:41:09,812
Hey. Have you ever flown
like Superman before?
966
00:41:09,849 --> 00:41:12,371
- Not really.
- You're gonna fly today, my man!
967
00:41:12,505 --> 00:41:14,439
[LAUGHTER]
968
00:41:16,017 --> 00:41:17,896
BELLOWS: Has it been 16 years?
969
00:41:17,991 --> 00:41:19,716
Seems like yesterday.
970
00:41:20,014 --> 00:41:21,613
You've certainly become
a fine young woman.
971
00:41:21,650 --> 00:41:23,991
Well, you haven't done so bad
for yourself, either.
972
00:41:24,214 --> 00:41:26,636
- I donated to your campaign.
- Really?
973
00:41:26,769 --> 00:41:28,793
- Thank you.
- My pleasure.
974
00:41:29,238 --> 00:41:31,920
So, why exactly
did you want to meet with me?
975
00:41:31,982 --> 00:41:35,092
I've been revisiting
the Rosemary Lynch case.
976
00:41:35,180 --> 00:41:37,261
VIOLET: In your case,
as in Gabrielle's,
977
00:41:37,298 --> 00:41:39,515
the prosecution used outdated,
978
00:41:39,552 --> 00:41:42,254
misogynistic tropes
about how women should behave.
979
00:41:42,313 --> 00:41:43,740
They kept the truth in the dark,
980
00:41:43,777 --> 00:41:45,827
and they allowed
this suffering to continue.
981
00:41:45,864 --> 00:41:48,631
I think, in Gabrielle's case,
the prosecution just
982
00:41:48,731 --> 00:41:50,678
believed another version of the truth.
983
00:41:50,759 --> 00:41:52,854
Have you ever seen this lantern before?
984
00:41:56,399 --> 00:41:59,067
I don't think so. Why?
985
00:41:59,273 --> 00:42:01,718
It was found at the bottom
of Cathedral Cove.
986
00:42:02,426 --> 00:42:03,967
It has been proven to be the weapon
987
00:42:04,004 --> 00:42:06,655
that was used to kill Rosemary.
988
00:42:08,649 --> 00:42:10,241
MADELINE: I mean, they weren't evil.
989
00:42:10,278 --> 00:42:13,088
They were just convinced
of the guilt of their defendant.
990
00:42:13,125 --> 00:42:16,510
If someone were to have been seen
991
00:42:16,547 --> 00:42:19,756
with this lantern the night
that Rosemary was murdered...
992
00:42:20,560 --> 00:42:22,919
...we could arrest that someone.
993
00:42:28,688 --> 00:42:29,818
Yeah.
994
00:42:30,010 --> 00:42:31,951
I remember it now.
995
00:42:33,109 --> 00:42:35,440
After Madeline and Rosemary
had the fight,
996
00:42:35,848 --> 00:42:38,344
Madeline chased after Rosemary.
997
00:42:39,247 --> 00:42:41,587
She was carrying that lantern.
998
00:42:42,800 --> 00:42:44,764
MADELINE: And that earnest belief,
999
00:42:44,801 --> 00:42:47,592
that unrelenting commitment to justice,
1000
00:42:47,629 --> 00:42:50,554
blinded them from seeing
any evidence of innocence.
1001
00:42:50,990 --> 00:42:52,950
- EASY: Excuse me, what's going on?
- WOMAN: Can we help you?
1002
00:42:52,986 --> 00:42:54,464
- What the Hell is this?
- MADELINE: Easy?
1003
00:42:54,529 --> 00:42:55,670
What's happening?
1004
00:42:55,707 --> 00:42:57,126
BELLOWS: Madeline Scott,
1005
00:42:57,662 --> 00:42:58,803
you are under arrest
1006
00:42:58,840 --> 00:43:00,285
for the murder of Rosemary Lynch.
1007
00:43:00,609 --> 00:43:02,276
[SHUTTER CLICKING]
1008
00:43:02,306 --> 00:43:04,006
synced & corrected by PopcornAWH
www.MY-SUBS.com